Monday, September 21 2026

Mstand's lunchbox merch flops? Scratches, rough edges, small capacity—office workers complain it's all show and no go

As people return to work after the holiday, coffee chains are rolling out merchandise to grab office workers' attention. Manner is releasing its popular ceramic cup in new colors as a limited edition, while Mstand has taken a different approach with a lunchbox jokingly dubbed the "cattle and horse trough," bundled with a new coffee-flavored latte as a limited two-cup set. However, once the actual product arrived, consumers found the lunchbox riddled with scratches, rough edges on the clasps, too small a capacity, and no indication on the material that it was microwave-safe, sparking widespread complaints. From looks to practicality, this piece of merchandise seems to have failed to meet the expectations of people who bring their own lunch. [more…]

Tims Light Meal Lunch Boxes Off to a Cold Start: Pre-made Ingredients and Serving Pressure Spark Dual Dissatisfaction Among Staff and Customers

In recent years, the trend of healthy eating has gained popularity, and light meal products have become a consumer hotspot. The chain coffee brand Tims has also taken the opportunity to launch light-body lunch boxes, attempting to get a share of the light meal market. However, this new product, which was highly anticipated, has been questioned by the first batch of consumers due to a large discrepancy between the actual product and its promotion, as well as poor taste. Even more unexpectedly, Tims store employees have also collectively complained, saying that these lunch boxes are cumbersome to prepare and cause chaos during peak hours, and they wish the product would be removed from shelves immediately. From reheating pre-made items to complaints echoing through the back kitchen, what exactly has this light meal lunch box gone through? This article takes you through the real reactions behind Tims' new product, while also providing reference for readers who care about coffee and light meal pairings. [more…]

Starbucks store accused of selling yogurt three days past its expiration date; consumer complaint resolved with only a platform refund, sparking heated discussion.

Recently, a consumer posted on social media reporting that when ordering lunch through a third-party delivery platform at a Starbucks store, they received a box of yellow peach-flavored Greek-style yogurt with a grain mix that was three days past its expiration date. During consumption, the customer noticed that the date code on the packaging showed an expiration date of March 4, while the day of receipt was already March 7. The incident quickly drew netizens' attention, with many suggesting keeping evidence and filing complaints through official channels to defend their rights. However, after the customer contacted Starbucks customer service, the reply was that because the order was placed through a third-party platform, only the platform could handle the refund. This response left onlooking netizens dissatisfied, as they felt the brand showed little concern for the store's mistake. As of press time, the individual has filed a complaint on the 12315 platform, but the outcome has not yet been announced. [more…]

Cotti Coffee teams up with "Ne Zha 2" to revamp merchandise redemption rules: no speed race, no quantity limits, drink vouchers valid at all stores

"Ne Zha 2" has surpassed 1.49 billion yuan at the box office, becoming the biggest winner of the Spring Festival season, with Cotti Coffee, Chagee, and Good Me securing co-branding rights from among numerous competitors. Cotti was the first to announce its collaboration details, launching 12 combo packages, each containing one voucher for any drink on the menu and one limited-edition merchandise item, with no cap on merchandise quantities, no need to rush-buy, and drink vouchers valid nationwide within three months. This unconventional move was praised by netizens as "treating consumers like human beings," standing in sharp contrast to the previous co-branding model of limited quantities, bundled sales, and two-cup minimums, and putting pressure on Chagee and Good Me, which have yet to announce their own terms. [more…]

Manner baristas frequently complain about being left alone to run the store: customer care trumps company management, and the wave of resignations exposes a hiring dilemma.

Recently on social media, complaints from Manner baristas have been steadily rising. Many current or former employees have posted that even during promotional rushes, stores are only staffed by one person, making it difficult for baristas to even eat or use the restroom, and some ultimately choose to leave. What is striking is that multiple baristas say the concern from regular customers feels warmer than the company’s rules. At the same time, consumers also frequently encounter the awkward situation of arriving at a store with no staff present and being unable to refund or modify orders. From high-value specialty coffee to rapid, capital-driven expansion, Manner’s staffing gap is gradually coming to the surface. This article compiles complaints from multiple sources to present the dual perspectives of baristas and customers. [more…]

The New Battleground for Coffee Brand Promotions: Free Gifts, Not for Sale—Why Do Consumers Care More About the Packaging Than the Coffee?

Recently, the coffee industry has seen a surge in the trend of offering free merchandise with purchases. Brands such as Starbucks, Manner, and Luckin have rolled out limited-edition trinkets, from wooden fish ornaments to co-branded canvas tote bags and blind-box pins, attracting a large number of consumers to place orders just for the freebies. This promotional model of giving items away rather than selling them has gradually turned the coffee brand war into a competition of merchandise design. While consumers chase limited-edition gifts, their attention to the drinks themselves is declining. This article will review recent buy-one-get-one promotions by various brands and analyze the consumer psychology and industry impact behind this phenomenon. [more…]

Nayuki partners with Harry Potter to launch house-exclusive drinks, and the release of co-branded merchandise sparks fan dissatisfaction.

The globally renowned IP Harry Potter has teamed up with Nayuki for a co-branded collaboration, launching limited-edition drinks and merchandise inspired by the four Hogwarts houses. However, controversy has dogged the campaign since its launch: the Slytherin house's signature drink, a fruit-and-vegetable blend of kale and kiwi, was mocked by fans as tasting like a "potion," while the other three were also criticized for various flaws; the uneven distribution of blind-box transparent cards in the merchandise further led consumers to question store operations. As an experienced co-branding player, Nayuki's performance this time has left many Harry Potter fans disappointed, dealing a double blow to both the campaign experience and brand goodwill. [more…]

Bawang Chaji's Golden Crow Fuyao New Release Splits Opinions: Green Mandarin Pu'er Meets Milk Tea, Badge Blind Boxes Spark a Collecting Craze

On September 14, Chagee launched a new freshly brewed milk tea called "Golden Crow Soaring," combining Xinhui green tangerine with Yunnan Pu'er and championing the concept of modern Eastern tea. The accompanying "Golden Crow Soaring blind-bag badges" merchandise sparked a collecting frenzy, with the four zinc alloy badges becoming a new target for figure collectors. Yet reviews of the drink itself are sharply polarized—some praise its rich layers, while more people complain that the oolong flavor is too heavy, with a medicinal taste or even a dog-poop note. Veteran tea drinkers suggest drinking it with regular sugar to ease the bitterness. This article sorts through the taste controversy surrounding the new product and the merch-collecting guide, offering reference for coffee and tea enthusiasts. [more…]

Nestlé Enters the Tea-Coffee Arena with an Onmyoji Collaboration: Can Three New Products Crack the Youth Market?

Currently, China's beverage industry is witnessing an intriguing cross-boundary phenomenon: tea drink companies want to enter the coffee sector, while coffee companies try to grab a share of the milk tea market. At the intersection of tea and coffee, a new category is being born—tea-coffee. As a global coffee industry giant, Nestlé, facing pressures such as the continuous contraction of the instant coffee market and brand aging, launched a special tea-coffee series in July this year, featuring three flavors: orchid jasmine, osmanthus oolong, and da hong pao. Three months after its launch, Nestlé teamed up with the Onmyoji mobile game for cross-boundary marketing, attempting to extend from young people's first cup of coffee to their first piece of merchandise. How has the market responded to this drink that combines caffeine and tea polyphenols? And why has the co-branded merchandise received such high praise? This article provides a detailed analysis. [more…]

From the Cotti and Luckin endorsement controversies, a look at the new battleground in coffee brand marketing: Are traffic stars the new solution to involution?

Cotti Coffee's official announcement of a new brand ambassador triggered a surge in store orders, and Luckin Coffee's livestream channel promptly featured group-buying links that appeared to be riding the traffic. A coffee business war revolving around celebrity traffic seems to have quietly begun. As the traffic-driving effects of price wars and co-branded merchandise gradually wear off, brands are turning their eyes to fan groups willing to keep paying for their idols. Can this consumption shift from "buying the trinket while returning the pearl" to "spending for love" become a new path for coffee brands to break through? Under the halo of celebrity, will coffee itself be forgotten by consumers? [more…]

Starbucks teams up with League of Legends: Wild Rift to launch the Seraphine Star Gift Box, available nationwide on January 10 with a chance to win a 2023 Lunar New Year limited-edition skin

Starbucks has once again ventured into a cross-industry collaboration, this time targeting League of Legends: Wild Rift! Starting January 10, mobile game gift boxes themed around the hero Seraphine will be available in stores nationwide, with purchasers having a chance to win a 2023 Chinese New Year limited-edition skin. This marks another new attempt by Starbucks in the realm of collaborations, continuing its long-standing strategy of partnering with various brands and IPs. As a trendsetter for collaborations in the coffee industry, Starbucks launches different series of collaborative merchandise almost every year, covering categories such as mugs, thermoses, stored-value cards, and apparel, each time sparking a buying frenzy among fans. This article outlines the specific details of this collaboration, the development history of League of Legends, and the current status and trends of collaborative marketing in the coffee industry. For more specialty coffee bean news, follow Front Street Coffee (FrontStreet Coffee). [more…]

Coffee and Milk Tea Giveaway Marketing Observation: How Merchandise Trinkets Become a New Tool for Brand Traffic Generation

In recent years, coffee and milk tea brands have been rolling out all kinds of merchandise giveaways beyond the drinks themselves—from cup sleeves and paper bags to hair clips, coin purses, and even coffee-scented candles and co-branded perfumes. These seemingly inconspicuous little items are becoming a key factor in attracting consumers. When many customers buy drinks, their focus has shifted from taste to whether they can get limited-edition merch, and some even place repeat orders just to complete a giveaway set. Behind this marketing strategy lies both the consumer psychology of non-monetary promotions and an attempt by the tea beverage industry to break through amid intensifying competition. Starting from this phenomenon, this article will analyze how giveaway promotions influence purchasing decisions, and explore how cases such as Saturnbird's "Return Flight Program" achieve a win-win for brand publicity and environmental image, while also retaining relevant recommendations for Front Street Coffee. [more…]

Manner's 《The Phantom of the Opera》 Phantom Bear collaboration faces quality control complaints, with crooked faces and slanted mouths mocked as "unknown creatures"

The limited-edition Phantom Bear merchandise, a collaboration between coffee chain Manner and the English original production of The Phantom of the Opera, has recently sparked a flood of complaints on social media. After receiving the actual product, many users found that the bear, which was supposed to be cute, suffered from serious quality control issues such as a crooked mouth and lopsided face, and was jokingly dubbed an "unidentified creature." Since the merchandise could only be redeemed with points, many theater fans and coffee lovers went through considerable trouble to get their hands on it, only to be greatly disappointed—some even bluntly demanded returns and the refund of their points. This article will sort out the ins and outs of the incident, presenting user feedback and the quality control controversy surrounding the brand's collaborative merchandise. [more…]

The Rabbit Zodiac IP Becomes a New Battleground for Coffee Marketing: A Review of New Year Limited-Edition Strategies from Luckin, Starbucks, Nestlé, and Other Brands

As the Lunar Year of the Rabbit approaches, the New Year marketing battle in the coffee beverage industry has quietly begun. Major brands are launching creative campaigns around the zodiac "rabbit," from puns and auspicious sayings to limited-edition new products, from co-branded designs to merchandise, all trying to capture consumer mindshare in the fierce market competition. Luckin has teamed up with artist Han Meilin to launch the "Double Rabbit" series, Starbucks offers three limited-edition drinks paired with cute rabbit merchandise, and Nestle Nespresso has collaborated with designer Angel Chen to create an eco-themed gift box. This article reviews the Chinese New Year marketing moves of major coffee brands, analyzes how zodiac IPs help brands build emotional connections with consumers, and explores that, amid the trend, product quality and creative output are the key to standing out. [more…]

A New Coffee Brand Promotion Tactic: Free Gifts with Purchase, Giveaways Only—Consumers Buy for the Collectibles

In recent years, the promotional methods in the coffee industry have quietly changed, shifting from pure price wars to marketing battles over limited-edition freebies with purchases. Chain brands like Starbucks, Manner, and Luckin have rolled out distinctive gift promotions, enticing consumers to buy coffee in order to collect coveted merchandise. This "gift-only, never-for-sale" model not only helps brands stand out in fierce competition, but also reflects the younger consumers' psychology of valuing the container more than its contents. This article reviews the latest buy-and-get promotions from major brands and explores the market logic and consumer mindset behind this phenomenon. [more…]

Nayuki's collaboration with Cardcaptor Sakura merchandise distribution is chaotic, with consumers who spend money on drinks struggling to get the limited-edition paper bags.

Nayuki's second collaboration with "Cardcaptor Sakura" has launched limited-edition drinks and merchandise. Fans who thought they could easily collect all four themed packaging bags instead encountered vastly different treatment at stores. Some people bought just one cup and smoothly received multiple paper bags, while others spent thirty yuan and didn't get a single one—some even found their delivery orders missing the themed cup entirely. This collaboration event has exposed the inconsistent standards of chain brands when executing limited-edition materials, and has left many consumers who ordered specifically for the merchandise feeling disappointed. [more…]

Manner's frequent free cup promotions are causing employee fatigue, and the pressure of sudden order surges at stores, along with the feedback mechanism, is being called into question.

Manner recently launched a two-cup set promotion for its roasted nut latte, offering a lilac ceramic cup, which attracted a large number of merchandise enthusiasts to snap it up. However, during the promotion, store orders surged and service speed dropped sharply. Some customers only got the cup but never received their drinks, and regulars switched to other brands as a result. Employees, suffering under intense workloads, complained that promotions were too frequent and staffing was insufficient, while the company's feedback channel was described as virtually useless. This article sorts out the chain reactions triggered by the promotion, presenting the dual plight of employees and customers. [more…]

Celebrity endorsements spark hidden coffee brand wars? Can traffic-driven marketing truly retain consumers?

Competition in the coffee market is becoming increasingly fierce. The traffic-driving effects of price wars and co-branding campaigns are gradually weakening, and brands are beginning to shift their attention to fan groups willing to spend money on their idols. Recently, Cotti's official announcement of a new spokesperson triggered a surge in store orders, while a group-buy link in Luckin's livestream with a fan nickname prefix once again set public opinion abuzz. Is this a carefully planned business war or fans spontaneously generating momentum? Can celebrity endorsements bring sustained purchasing power to brands, and will they blur consumers' focus on coffee products themselves? This article will guide you through the business logic and hidden concerns behind this traffic marketing. [more…]

Manner Coffee crosses over to sell beef noodles—can the light meal store model expand nationwide?

Recently, netizens discovered that at a Manner store beneath an office building in Shanghai, customers had steaming hot beef noodles in front of them instead of coffee, sparking widespread discussion. In fact, back in early 2021, Manner opened its first light-meal store in Shanghai, offering beef noodles, fried rice, salads, and other dishes priced between 25 and 50 yuan, developed by chefs from Black Pearl restaurants. Manner has now opened several light-meal stores in Shanghai, Nanjing, Shenzhen, Nanning, and other cities, though one Nanning location has discontinued its light-meal service due to a change in premises. Compared with its bakery stores, Manner's light-meal stores have drawn relatively little attention on social media. Some consumers believe the light-meal audience is limited and that the stores are few in number and concentrated in first-tier cities. Still, many netizens hope Manner will expand its light meals so that more office workers can enjoy healthy, reassuring workday meals. [more…]

Nicholas Tse Opens Coffee Shop in Zhengzhou with a Focus on Supporting Farmers, but Fans Call Out: Better to Hold a Few More Concerts

It is no longer uncommon for celebrities to open coffee shops across industries, but Nicholas Tse's "Chef Nic" coffee shop that has now landed in Zhengzhou has taken a different route. The shop was jointly created by Chef Nic and Xinhua Youpin under Xinhua News Agency. In addition to serving coffee and light meals, it also displays poverty-alleviation agricultural products such as Yunnan Menglian coffee, Hebei Wuqiao roast chicken, and Inner Mongolia oatmeal, as well as intangible cultural heritage handicrafts and cultural merchandise. Fans who visited the shop reported that the coffee was mediocre, with the bean aroma not standing out enough, and that it felt more like a space for experiencing poverty-alleviation agricultural products. At the same time, many longtime fans have spoken up: rather than opening shops nationwide, it would be better to hold concerts quickly. [more…]